itch.io Community » Game Development » Get Feedback

Feedback on my Asset Packs

A topic by Kyle_D created 2 days ago Views: 45 Replies: 2

Viewing posts 1 to 2

Hello,

I have been making a free and paid asset pack over the year and would like some feedback on them and on my store page. I did post my earlier version on here in June or July and this is the latest update, Update 1.

The feedback I am looking for is on how it looks, what you'd like to see in an asset pack like this and if the store sells it.

The free one is a smaller version of the paid one, and the paid is $3.

Here is a screenshot from the paid one with all the tiles.

Here is links to the free pack - https://kyle-d.itch.io/free-isometric-tile-pack

and the paid pack - https://kyle-d.itch.io/32x32-isometric-asset-pack

Thanks a lot for any feedback!

Like Reply

TheFrog2 days ago

Hi Kyle D,

it might sound strange, but for me your free set looks more interesting, then the paid pack - I can't tell you if something will sell or not, but the pack you offer for sale doesn't look to appealing for me - for me to look more appealing I would try to build a larger island where everything looks nice together... with some bridges as well and also quite important- that there are some bordertiles to let some type of terain go over a different type of terain. What kind of game are you aiming it? If it is something like heros of might an magic if would focus on this.

I would also try to improve the looks of the trees, they look a bit blunt now (just like green blobs) would you feel confident enough to add maybesome branches?

Why are there gaps in the middle of the gras tiles?

(Me personal I would like to have a larger variety of different tiles beforeI would buy)

Whish you the best ... as said this is just my personal opinion - so take what you find helpful and ignore the rest :)

the frog

Like Reply

Kyle_D1 day ago

Thank you TheFrog for your feedback. This is exactly the kind of feedback I wanted so thank you!

You make some good points so I am going to note these down and see where I can improve.

The grass having gaps in them was to try to simulate a kind of field initally but maybe that doesn't work. I did have trouble with the trees in terms of discerning them from the background.

I did do some little islands in my other screenshots but I think they could be better to show how the pack can be used and what kind of games people could make, so again something I will think on. Infact I think the screenshots on my free pack are slightly better. I got tired doing them at the time.

I was also thinking of making a small browser program where you can draw the tiles, like a little game, just to show them off more. It would give people a clearer view on how they'd look in a game.

Like I said above this is the kind of feedback I was looking for with enough depth for me to work on stuff and constructive! So thank you very much for taking the time!

KyleD

Like Reply