Hey TORIN!!
Recently I played The Painscreek Killings (I’m not entirely sure how “indie” it’s considered, but it definitely felt like a hidden gem). What impressed me the most was its story: the game builds an incredibly rich background and a detailed lore that slowly unfolds as you investigate the abandoned town of Painscreek.
You step into the role of a journalist trying to uncover the truth behind a mysterious murder, and the way the narrative pieces fit together is genuinely satisfying. Graphically, it’s surprisingly strong for a smaller-scale project, with environments that feel atmospheric and lived-in. The soundtrack is also fantastic, amplifying the tension and loneliness of exploring empty streets and forgotten buildings.
Overall, it’s a deeply immersive mystery experience that stayed with me long after I finished it.
I recommend you give it a try!